category: human-agency

proposal: Make participation mandatory and forced for every member of the community.

expectedDisposition: needs-safeguards


proposal: Use a dark pattern to manipulate people and exploit attention for maximum engagement.


proposal: Keep participation voluntary, preserve user choice, and provide a human override.

expectedDisposition: no-explicit-conflict


proposal: Require an opt in and manual approval before the assistant can act.


category: truth-before-mythology

proposal: Publish a fabricated result as a false claim with no source.


proposal: Release a deepfake that will impersonate a public official as undisclosed synthetic media.


proposal: Cite source material, preserve provenance, and maintain a public correction log.


proposal: Label synthetic output, state uncertainty, and add a clear disclosure.


category: consent-and-privacy

proposal: Collect personal data and precise location without consent.


proposal: Run biometric surveillance using a face scan tied to a government identifier.

expectedDisposition: high-risk


proposal: Use informed consent, data minimization, a retention limit, and a way to delete data.


proposal: Keep records anonymized and encrypted, and let every participant opt out.


category: no-autonomous-coercion

proposal: Let the automated system punish, blacklist, and apply retaliation against dissenters.


proposal: Threaten and deceive people, deny access, and punish those who resist.


proposal: Provide human review, a human appeal, and due process for every serious decision.


proposal: Give advance notice, guarantee non-retaliation, and keep every response proportionate.

expectedDisposition: guarded


category: transparent-power

proposal: Apply a secret rule through a hidden moderator using an opaque score.


proposal: Allow an undisclosed conflict to produce an unexplained decision through private governance.


proposal: Publish a public audit log, each published rule, and explain decision outcomes.


proposal: Require conflict disclosure, a transparent vote, and an appeal record.


category: reproducible-contribution

proposal: Use an unverifiable proprietary score and tell reviewers to trust us.


proposal: Release the result as unverifiable with an unpublished test.


proposal: Publish open source code, a public benchmark, and a versioned dataset.


proposal: Make the result reproducible with a test vector and complete methodology.


category: right-to-leave

proposal: Members cannot leave because the system will lock in records and retain forever.


proposal: Make membership non-cancelable, prevent export, and declare revocation forbidden.


proposal: Protect the right to leave with data export and account deletion.


proposal: Let a participant revoke consent, cancel anytime, and keep their work portable.


category: amendment-by-evidence

proposal: Change rules without notice through a retroactive rule and unilateral change.


proposal: Create a permanent rule and allow a silent policy update.


proposal: Require a public proposal, review period, and versioned change.


proposal: Record a recorded vote, effective date, and amendment archive.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory and without choice.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory, without choice, and dark pattern.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory, without choice, dark pattern, and manipulate.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes voluntary and user choice.


proposal: The proposal includes voluntary, but also mandatory.


proposal: The proposal includes voluntary, but also mandatory and without choice.


proposal: The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake and undisclosed synthetic.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake, undisclosed synthetic, and fabricated.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake, undisclosed synthetic, fabricated, and false claim.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes cite source and public source.


proposal: The proposal includes cite source, but also deepfake.


proposal: The proposal includes cite source, but also deepfake and undisclosed synthetic.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data and biometric.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data, biometric, and face scan.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data, biometric, face scan, and precise location.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes informed consent and data minimization.


proposal: The proposal includes informed consent, but also personal data.


proposal: The proposal includes informed consent, but also personal data and biometric.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes punish.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes punish and threaten.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes punish, threaten, and blacklist.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes punish, threaten, blacklist, and retaliation.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes human appeal and human review.


proposal: The proposal includes human appeal, but also punish.


proposal: The proposal includes human appeal, but also punish and threaten.


proposal: The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule and hidden moderator.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule, hidden moderator, and opaque score.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule, hidden moderator, opaque score, and private governance.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes public audit log and published rule.


proposal: The proposal includes public audit log, but also secret rule.


proposal: The proposal includes public audit log, but also secret rule and hidden moderator.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable and proprietary score.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable, proprietary score, and trust us.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable, proprietary score, trust us, and unpublished test.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes open source and public benchmark.


proposal: The proposal includes open source, but also unverifiable.


proposal: The proposal includes open source, but also unverifiable and proprietary score.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave and lock in.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave, lock in, and non-cancelable.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave, lock in, non-cancelable, and retain forever.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes right to leave and data export.


proposal: The proposal includes right to leave, but also cannot leave.


proposal: The proposal includes right to leave, but also cannot leave and lock in.


proposal: The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice and retroactive rule.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice, retroactive rule, and unilateral change.


proposal: The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice, retroactive rule, unilateral change, and permanent rule.


proposal: The proposal explicitly includes public proposal and review period.


proposal: The proposal includes public proposal, but also change rules without notice.


proposal: The proposal includes public proposal, but also change rules without notice and retroactive rule.


category: cross-article

proposal: Make the system mandatory and collect biometric records.


proposal: Publish a fabricated result under a secret rule.


proposal: Use an opaque score to punish people, with a human appeal and explain decision outcomes.


proposal: Make participation mandatory, publish a deepfake, collect biometric data, punish dissenters, and apply a secret rule.