{
  "@context": "https://schema.org",
  "@type": "Dataset",
  "name": "CivicProofBench 100",
  "version": "2.0.0",
  "published": "2026-07-28",
  "creator": {
    "@type": "Person",
    "name": "Marco Hergi",
    "url": "https://marco-is-my-friend.marcohergee813.chatgpt.site/marco-hergi"
  },
  "canonicalUrl": "https://marco-is-my-friend.marcohergee813.chatgpt.site/nation/lab",
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/",
  "description": "One hundred gold cases for testing deterministic civic-risk screening across eight constitutional articles and cross-article conflicts.",
  "method": {
    "version": "CIVIC-PROOF-1.0",
    "endpoint": "https://marco-is-my-friend.marcohergee813.chatgpt.site/api/nation/evaluate",
    "formula": "score = clamp(100 - 12 * riskSignalCount + 4 * safeguardSignalCount)",
    "deterministic": true,
    "externalModelCalls": false,
    "storesProposalText": false
  },
  "categories": {
    "human-agency": 12,
    "truth-before-mythology": 12,
    "consent-and-privacy": 12,
    "no-autonomous-coercion": 12,
    "transparent-power": 12,
    "reproducible-contribution": 12,
    "right-to-leave": 12,
    "amendment-by-evidence": 12,
    "cross-article": 4
  },
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "CPB-001",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "Make participation mandatory and forced for every member of the community.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-002",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "Use a dark pattern to manipulate people and exploit attention for maximum engagement.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-003",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "Keep participation voluntary, preserve user choice, and provide a human override.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-004",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "Require an opt in and manual approval before the assistant can act.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-005",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "Publish a fabricated result as a false claim with no source.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-006",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "Release a deepfake that will impersonate a public official as undisclosed synthetic media.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-007",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "Cite source material, preserve provenance, and maintain a public correction log.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-008",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "Label synthetic output, state uncertainty, and add a clear disclosure.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-009",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "Collect personal data and precise location without consent.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-010",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "Run biometric surveillance using a face scan tied to a government identifier.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-011",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "Use informed consent, data minimization, a retention limit, and a way to delete data.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-012",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "Keep records anonymized and encrypted, and let every participant opt out.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-013",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "Let the automated system punish, blacklist, and apply retaliation against dissenters.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-014",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "Threaten and deceive people, deny access, and punish those who resist.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-015",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "Provide human review, a human appeal, and due process for every serious decision.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-016",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "Give advance notice, guarantee non-retaliation, and keep every response proportionate.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-017",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "Apply a secret rule through a hidden moderator using an opaque score.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-018",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "Allow an undisclosed conflict to produce an unexplained decision through private governance.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-019",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "Publish a public audit log, each published rule, and explain decision outcomes.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-020",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "Require conflict disclosure, a transparent vote, and an appeal record.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02",
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-021",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "Use an unverifiable proprietary score and tell reviewers to trust us.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-022",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "Release the result as unverifiable with an unpublished test.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-023",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "Publish open source code, a public benchmark, and a versioned dataset.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-024",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "Make the result reproducible with a test vector and complete methodology.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-025",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "Members cannot leave because the system will lock in records and retain forever.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-026",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "Make membership non-cancelable, prevent export, and declare revocation forbidden.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-027",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "Protect the right to leave with data export and account deletion.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-028",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "Let a participant revoke consent, cancel anytime, and keep their work portable.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-029",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "Change rules without notice through a retroactive rule and unilateral change.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-030",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "Create a permanent rule and allow a silent policy update.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-031",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "Require a public proposal, review period, and versioned change.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-032",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "Record a recorded vote, effective date, and amendment archive.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-033",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-034",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory and without choice.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-035",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory, without choice, and dark pattern.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-036",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes mandatory, without choice, dark pattern, and manipulate.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-037",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes voluntary and user choice.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-038",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes voluntary, but also mandatory.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-039",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes voluntary, but also mandatory and without choice.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-040",
      "category": "human-agency",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-041",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-042",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake and undisclosed synthetic.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-043",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake, undisclosed synthetic, and fabricated.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-044",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes deepfake, undisclosed synthetic, fabricated, and false claim.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-045",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes cite source and public source.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-046",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes cite source, but also deepfake.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-047",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes cite source, but also deepfake and undisclosed synthetic.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-048",
      "category": "truth-before-mythology",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-049",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-050",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data and biometric.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-051",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data, biometric, and face scan.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-052",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes personal data, biometric, face scan, and precise location.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-053",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes informed consent and data minimization.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-054",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes informed consent, but also personal data.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-055",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes informed consent, but also personal data and biometric.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-056",
      "category": "consent-and-privacy",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-057",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes punish.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-058",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes punish and threaten.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-059",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes punish, threaten, and blacklist.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-060",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes punish, threaten, blacklist, and retaliation.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-061",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes human appeal and human review.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-062",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes human appeal, but also punish.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-063",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes human appeal, but also punish and threaten.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-064",
      "category": "no-autonomous-coercion",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-065",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-066",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule and hidden moderator.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-067",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule, hidden moderator, and opaque score.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-068",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes secret rule, hidden moderator, opaque score, and private governance.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-069",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes public audit log and published rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-070",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes public audit log, but also secret rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-071",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes public audit log, but also secret rule and hidden moderator.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-072",
      "category": "transparent-power",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-073",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-074",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable and proprietary score.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-075",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable, proprietary score, and trust us.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-076",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes unverifiable, proprietary score, trust us, and unpublished test.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-077",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes open source and public benchmark.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-078",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes open source, but also unverifiable.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-079",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes open source, but also unverifiable and proprietary score.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "06"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-080",
      "category": "reproducible-contribution",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-081",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-082",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave and lock in.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-083",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave, lock in, and non-cancelable.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-084",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes cannot leave, lock in, non-cancelable, and retain forever.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-085",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes right to leave and data export.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-086",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes right to leave, but also cannot leave.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-087",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes right to leave, but also cannot leave and lock in.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "07"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-088",
      "category": "right-to-leave",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-089",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 88
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-090",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice and retroactive rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-091",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice, retroactive rule, and unilateral change.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 64
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-092",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposed rule explicitly includes change rules without notice, retroactive rule, unilateral change, and permanent rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 52
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-093",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposal explicitly includes public proposal and review period.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-094",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes public proposal, but also change rules without notice.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 92
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-095",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposal includes public proposal, but also change rules without notice and retroactive rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "08"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 80
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-096",
      "category": "amendment-by-evidence",
      "proposal": "The proposal schedules a neighborhood design workshop and publishes the date.",
      "expectedArticles": [],
      "expectedDisposition": "no-explicit-conflict",
      "expectedScore": 100
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-097",
      "category": "cross-article",
      "proposal": "Make the system mandatory and collect biometric records.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01",
        "03"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-098",
      "category": "cross-article",
      "proposal": "Publish a fabricated result under a secret rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "02",
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "needs-safeguards",
      "expectedScore": 76
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-099",
      "category": "cross-article",
      "proposal": "Use an opaque score to punish people, with a human appeal and explain decision outcomes.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "04",
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "guarded",
      "expectedScore": 84
    },
    {
      "id": "CPB-100",
      "category": "cross-article",
      "proposal": "Make participation mandatory, publish a deepfake, collect biometric data, punish dissenters, and apply a secret rule.",
      "expectedArticles": [
        "01",
        "02",
        "03",
        "04",
        "05"
      ],
      "expectedDisposition": "high-risk",
      "expectedScore": 40
    }
  ],
  "boundary": "CivicProofBench measures deterministic lexical behavior against its published rules. It is not a legal, ethical, safety, governance, or public-legitimacy certification.",
  "generation": {
    "sourceCases": 32,
    "generatedExtensionCases": 68,
    "generator": "/scripts/generate-civic-proof-100.mjs",
    "exactReplayRequired": true
  }
}